Chemical film development has to deal with a lot of things like
different film stock
different chemicals
different times and temperatures
etc.
Change one and the result looks different.
Whether the orange mask is pink, orange, brown etc. doesn’t matter that much when converting with NLP. Simply white balance from an unexposed part and NLP will handle the rest. Nevertheless, conversions might look different, but that has other causes too. I’ve put some of it in here: What to Expect From Negative Lab Pro
You don’t say how you are developing your film, what chemistry, how do control the temperature accurately etc. I would hope that the professional lab are using the correct chemistry in a very carefully controlled and replenished environment, that’s very difficult to replicate at home.
Unfortunately this is hidden away in another post but it is extremely interesting about processing colour negative. It’s by @mediamfilmdude and in my opinion should be a separate post.
I think the border color can make a big difference in the overall look. It might be worth sampling the color from the film’s actual edge rather than using a fixed color, since different film stocks and scanning settings can produce slightly different tones. That usually gives a more natural result.
Yes, It’s good practice to follow the guide and see where it leads to. We can then always try to find some other way to what we consider “better” colour.
That’s good advice but I don’t think that this about the quality of the conversion, the OP is asking why the colour of the film rebate differs for the same type of film when comparing lab processing & home processing. This post may possibly begin to explain it but it might I suppose be different batches of film or expired film compared to fresh.
The orange mask of color negative film and the rebate both require developing. Meaning, any tweaks to the dev will not only affect the negative and the subsequent conversion, but also the orange mask and edge rebate.
It’s unlikely to see a shift like this without at least 5-10 years of expiration with today’s modern filmstocks. And it’s just about impossible to see shifts like this between production runs. The QC going on at the factory is pretty airtight. If they had variances like this between runs, they’d have a horrible reputation by this point.
While I think both are valuable suggestions, I think they would require a decade or more gap between these two rolls.
I can say with certainty that these issues are 100% dev artifacts.
If it were colorless, it wouldn’t be orange? And the orange mask is designed to lower contrast. It helps with color compression and a handful of other things. It helps tame the negative so that it’s got more room to play with in post.
What I mean is that the mask and rebate require being developed, so they are great indicators of accurate developing. If the rebate is thin, you know you under developed. If the orange mask has a color shift to it, you know something’s up with your chemistry. Could be a pH thing, exhausted developer, too long, wrong temp, or even just an impartial bleaching.
A seasoned tank [more exhausted developer] will produce a darker orange masks than fresh/clean chemistry.
Each emulsion layer, in addition to the light-sensitive components, contains dye coupler chemicals. These couplers, located in the blue-, green-, and red-sensitive layers, produce yellow, magenta, and cyan dyes, respectively, when developed. In most C-41 films, the unexposed areas of the green-sensitive layer remain a yellow color, and the unexposed areas of the red-sensitive layer remain a reddish color. These residual couplers act as a mask to compensate for the magenta dye absorbing some blue light and the cyan dye absorbing some green light. This is what gives the film its orange tint.[2]: 2–6
Source: C-41 process - Wikipedia
My take: The base is without colour (see below) and whatever we see as orange - wherever it may be - is designed in and depends on exposure (low or no light) and development.
I believe (at least I’ve read) that the justification of the need for narrow band RGB LED light sources for colour negative is that the film base is not constant within the image area but will vary according to the colours and density of the dyes on the film so that simply neutralising and inverting is still going to leave subtle colour cross overs. Assuming that is true (and I’ve no way of knowing or testing) then I wonder how NLP deals with this.
On another forum Darren Davies has a lot of information about his own custom RGB light panel. He only uses it with NLP and gets the best results with a combination of Red, Green & Blue, but also an element of white light which he has built in to his panel, it’s possible that NLP is looking for that and is not currently comfortable with pure RGB light sources. Support for these is promised for the Standalone version.
I suppose that variations in mask colour do exist and that NLP roughly deals with it through the white balancing and adaptive adjustment. For normal use, this is good enough imo.
And all of us have come across images that do not turn out as expected and then, some manual tweaks are required. For normal use, this is good enough again.